Follow us on:
  • Google +1
  • twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Sydney's scandalous toxic waste plan by government

Hunter’s Hill is a predominantly wealthy suburb of Sydney with average house prices of around AUD $1.3 million and a harbour-side community made up predominantly of professionals, managers and other traditionally middle to high-income workers. Penrith, on the other hand, located just over 50 kilometres from Sydney’s CBD, is not as affluent, with average property values of around AUD $280,000.

It is for this reason that a class-bias has been suggested by some in regard to the New South Wales government’s decision to have 5,800 tonnes of toxic waste moved from Hunter’s Hill to a landfill site in Kemps Creek, which is on the outskirts of Penrith. The waste is the by-product of a uranium smelter that operated in Hunter’s Hill before the area became a well-to-do suburb with detached homes and waterfront residences.

The toxic waste, according to Sydney news reports, has been categorised by nuclear scientists with the Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation as ‘hazardous’ in 1987, but was recently re-categorised by the state government ahead of their plans to have it relocated, despite some samples showing radioactive levels seven times the level considered to be hazardous.

The waste has been a headache for the local government for decades.

In the past several years, six people in the area of Nelson’s Parade, where the toxic waste is located, have died of cancer, though there is no clear link between their deaths and the presence of the waste, which is radioactive, but not, the government insists, at dangerous levels.

The plots of land occupied by the waste are worth a combined AUD $9 million and the Sun-Herald has previously reported that the government plans to sell these plots once the waste has been removed. The financial motivation, as well as the under-handed nature of the government’s plans, have caused many Sydney news media houses to label the proposed project a scandal.

Indeed, the information obtained by the Sun-Herald was only done so forcibly through the Government Information (Public Access) Act and shows that the New South Wales government knew the plan would be contentious and tried to deliberately delay informing the City of Penrith of their decision until after they’d signed the contract with SITA Environmental Solutions, the private company that owns the landfill site in Kemps Creek.

“We would prefer to brief council after a contract has been executed between SPA and SITA, so that there is certainty on SITA’s commitment to accept the waste and to mitigate the impact of any opposition by council on the progress of the project,” read part an internal briefing note from early in 2010, written by the State Property Authority (SPA), the government agency responsible for the contaminated land.

Internal emails further show that the SPA was unwilling to “pander” to Penrith Council’s requests for further information, saying the less they knew of the waste the better.

According to the internal documents obtained, SITA would be paid AUD $3.5 million to accept the waste and was told to prepare for a negative reaction from the local community, including protests at the landfill and attempts to block access to the site.

The nuclear scientists that took 266 samples from the plots in 1987 and deemed many of them to be hazardous, recommended that the nuclear waste be disposed of in the specialised manner required of most nuclear waste, but New South Wales does not have the facilities for such disposal and this is part of the reason why the land has remained contaminated since 1916 when the uranium smelter closed down.

The government, in reclassifying the waste as non-hazardous, used data compiled by consultants from Environ, who took just 19 samples and came to the conclusion that the uranium smelter’s by-product was ‘restricted solid waste’, rather than hazardous waste, and therefore requires no special disposal.

Despite this, the government had planned to move the 5,800 tonnes of radioactive waste through the city in specially sealed trucks, but abandoned the plan only when Sydney news media began reporting on it. In an abrupt about-turn, Kristina Keneally, the Premier of New South Wales, informed the public that the Land and Property Management Authority had been instructed to examine other options.

While maintaining that the waste was not dangerous, the premier indicated that “given the community concern regarding this material, I have instructed [the Land and Property Management Authority] to examine alternative options – including interstate or overseas locations – for the transfer of this waste.”

This presents the possibility of a smaller, less powerful and less wealthy country within Australia’s sphere of influence being saddled with the waste on Sydney’s behalf, much like the city originally intended for Penrith.

Comments

More Sydney News

RSS
  • 250 migrants feared drowned off Italian coast

    The Sydney News.Net - Thursday 3rd October, 2013

    The Italian coast guard Thursday recovered the bodies of scores of migrants after a ship carrying them to Italy reportedly caught fire and sank off the Sicilian island of Lampedusa. As many as 250 migrants were feared drowned in the shipwreck. "A total (of) 150 people have been rescued and 82 bodies have been recovered," the mayor of Lampedusa, Giusi Nicolini, told AKI. Local fishermen were ...

  • Cordner deserves World Cup chance Fittler

    ABC - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Sydney 2000 Former Test captain Brad Fittler says Roosters back-rower Boyd Cordner should join Australia's World Cup squad regardless of his grand final performance.Cordner is desperate to prove his fitness ahead of the decider against Manly, having been sidelined for seven weeks following ankle surgery.His selection would take to six the number of genuine Kangaroos candidates on display ...

  • Drone hits Harbour Bridge

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Police are searching for the owner of a quad-copter that crashed into the Harbour Bridge sparking an investigation by the Civil Aviation Safety ...

  • Sineads third letter the unfriendliest of all

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    wrote an open letter to Cyrus, asking her to reject music industry pressure to "prostitute" herself after a series of raunchy performances and music videos. Cyrus responded by mocking O'Connor and comparing her to troubled actress Amanda Bynes, who is undergoing treatment in a private facility near Los Angeles on doctors' ...

  • White leads Victoria to win over South Australia

    ABC - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Sydney 2000 Victoria has emerged as the early pace-setter in the one-day cricket competition after Cameron White helped power the side to a six-wicket win over South Australia at Bankstown Oval on Friday.Set 233 to win, the Bushrangers always looked to have the chase covered and got home with 13 balls to spare.It was the Bushrangers' second win from as many games, while the Redbacks were ...

  • PH Navy sends team to Australia for first time for training exercises with counterparts

    Inquirer Global Nation - Friday 4th October, 2013

    AFP FILE PHOTO MANILA, Philippines - Representatives from the Philippine Navy for the first time went to Australia where they joined their counterparts in training exercises as part of the Status of Visiting Forces Agreement that was ratified by the Philippine Senate in 2012. Lieutenant Commander Gregory Fabic, Navy spokesman, said on Friday that the Filipino sailors have been in Australia ...

  • The most successful NRL team is ...

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Brisbane Broncos are officially the most successful team in Australian rugby league history. Data obtained by Fairfax Media shows the Queensland team are the most successful when it comes to the number of titles won as a percentage of their time in the competition. Despite only being founded in 1988, the Broncos rank ahead of 20-time premiership winners South ...

  • ABC stands by Chaser bestiality skit

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Dismissed complaint The ABC stands by the Chaser boys' skit aired on The Hamster Decides last month. The newspaper columnist depicted by ...

  • Australia extends time for decision on ADM acquisition of Graincorp

    Reuters - Friday 4th October, 2013

    CANBERRA (Reuters) - Australian Treasurer Joe Hockey on Friday extended the time period for a foreign investment decision on Archer Daniels Midland Co's (ADM.N) acquisition of Australian grain handler GrainCorp Ltd (GNC.AX), which is now due ...

  • Mystery drone collides with Sydney Harbour Bridge

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    A mystery drone has crashed into the Sydney Harbour Bridge, causing counter terrorism officers to be alerted and an investigation by the Civil Aviation and Safety Authority. The incident occurred on Wednesday, just a day before the start of the International Navy Fleet Review, which has already drawn thousands of spectators to the harbour and foreshore. However police believe the two are not ...

  • Engine problems force China Airlines plane to land in Australias Cairns

    China Daily - Friday 4th October, 2013

    /enpproperty--> BRISBANE, Australia -- A China Airlines flight was forced to make an emergency landing at Cairns Airport in Australia's Queensland due to engine failure, local media reported Friday. The flight from Sydney to Taipei was diverted to Cairns after engine problems were detected over Cape York in Far North Queensland. ...

  • Sineads second letter not so friendly

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    wrote an open letter to Cyrus, asking her to reject music industry pressure to "prostitute" herself after a series of raunchy performances and music videos. Cyrus responded by mocking O'Connor and comparing her to troubled actress Amanda Bynes, who is undergoing treatment in a private facility near Los Angeles on doctors' ...

  • Depressed Corby maintains innocence

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Schapelle Corby has continued to deny all knowledge of the drugs found in her boogie board bag, reiterating her innocence to authorities assessing her suitability for ...

  • Psychotic killer battle of appeals

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Psychiatrists agree that Renzo Da-Pra was ‘‘suffering from a disease of the mind’’ when he fatally bashed his father at their Wetherill Park home before running next door, murdering his 12 year-old neighbour and slitting her grandmother’s throat. Such was his psychotic state, his lawyers argue, that he then set himself on fire in a suicide attempt outside hospital ...

  • RPT-Fitch affirms Australias Crown at BBB outlook stable

    Reuters - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Fri Oct 4, 2013 3:00am EDT (Repeat for additional subscribers) Oct 4 (Reuters) - (The following statement was released by the rating agency) Fitch Ratings has affirmed Australia-based gaming and entertainment operator Crown Limited's (Crown) Long-term Issuer Default Rating (IDR) and its senior unsecured rating at 'BBB'. The Outlook on the IDR is Stable. Crown's assets in ...

  • Preview Argentina v Australia

    Planet Rugby - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Humbled at Newlands last weekend, Australia arrive in Rosario at their lowest to face a hungry Argentina. The Wallabies were out of the match after only 20 minutes against South Africa in Cape Town, slumping to their fourth defeat in five matches under new boss Ewen McKenzie since he arrived at the helm.Those other defeats have included shipping 112 points in their first three matches of this ...

  • Australia shares fall on U.S. shutdown snap 7 straight weekly gain

    Reuters - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Fri Oct 4, 2013 2:22am EDT (Updates to close) SYDNEY Oct 4 (Reuters) - Australian shares fell 0.5 percent on Friday as investors worried that political brinkmanship in Washington could have more serious consequences for the world's largest economy. The S&P/ASX 200 index fell 26.9 points to 5,208.0. The benchmark fell 1.9 percent for the week, its biggest one-week fall since early June, ...

  • Life sentence given for shooting Tamworth policeman

    ABC - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Tamworth 2340 A man who murdered a policeman at Tamwoth in northern New South Wales has been jailed for life.Michael Jacobs, 49, shot Senior Constable David Rixon after the officer stopped his car for a random breath test in March last year.Colleagues who rushed to the scene were unable to revive the 40-year-old.Under laws the NSW Government introduced in June 2011, courts must impose life ...

  • NBL finalises de-merger with Basketball Australia

    ABC - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Sydney 2000 Basketball Australia (BA) and the National Basketball League (NBL) have finalised their de-merger just a week out from the 2013/2014 season opener.The newly-formed independent NBL has now taken full control of the league and its brand after the split was officially ratified in Sydney on Friday.The NBL has also re-negotiated a TV deal with Network Ten, extending an agreement between ...

  • Johns polish on Manlys title quest

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Manly five-eighth Kieran Foran credits Andrew Johns with adding the polish that has the Sea Eagles on the cusp on premiership glory and NRL domination. Foran describes working with Johns, who he considers the greatest rugby league player of alltime, as "outrageous". And he says he and fellow half Daly Cherry-Evans have taken their games to a new level since the club secured exclusive ...

  • Magnificent seven make magic

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    They led the first division, which included ships from Singapore and Malaysia. Police inflatables and even police on wetbikes bobbed around and made sure the big guys had a clear passage. Division two was led soon after by the seafaring Brits with their futuristic-looking HMS Daring, an impressive guided missile destroyer. New Zealand followed with a frigate and India with a guided missile ...

  • King of the corporate spenders

    Sydney Morning Herald - Friday 4th October, 2013

    Market darling to corporate outcast EXCLUSIVE: Former Leighton boss Wal King repaid $40,000 worth of unauthorised expenses – including trips to Madrid, a $780 meal at Sydney's Rockpool restaurant and stays at luxury hotels – that he billed to a company credit card in the weeks after he had left the construction giant. A Fairfax Media investigation can also reveal a small number ...

More Sydney News

News from around our Network

Showing 1 thru 3 out of 10More from our network

Buffalo News.Net

  • Marrone holds Byrd out of Cleveland game
  • EJ Stevie latest in a string of injuries
  • Doug Marrone I dont think Im ever going to tell someone not to score

Honolulu News.Net

  • EXCLUSIVE State lawmaker faces new campaign fines
  • Government shutdown Obama cancels Asia trip
  • How has the shutdown affected you

Tucson News.Net

  • Arizona Gov. Brewer local businesses fight to reopen Grand Canyon
  • Man found in burning north Tucson home hospitalized
  • Deputies looking for Tucson-area armed robber

Showing 4 thru 6 out of 10More from our network

Atlanta News.Net

  • Atlanta company raising $100K for robotic bartender
  • Tree falls on house in southwest Atlanta
  • Clayton County boy missing

Boston News.Net

  • Parents Westbrook girl had methadone in system
  • Parents fight shooting range near Conn. school
  • Brother of slain woman urges prosecutors to charge ‘Whitey’ Bulger with her murder

Chicago News.Net

  • Poll Vault How long do you think the government shutdown will last
  • Win Bears Tickets With WBBM
  • From Louisiana to Florida Gulf Coast Braces for Tropical Storm Karen

Showing 7 thru 9 out of 10More from our network

Cleveland News.Net

  • Browns lose QB Hoyer in 37-24 win over Bills
  • Losses pile up for Bills in 37-24 loss to Browns
  • Weeden Comes Off Bench to Inspire Browns Win Over Bills

St Louis News.Net

  • Where to find todays Cardinals game on TV
  • Infrastructure charge approved for Ameren Missouri
  • Last Food Truck Friday of the season

The Virginia Beach News.Net

  • Friday weather Sunny and warm weather to continue through weekend
  • Offensive shakeup in works for struggling Virginia
  • Different QBs starting for West Virginia Baylor

Showing item 10 out of 10More from our network

Atlantic City News.Net

  • Investment group hunting for Atlantic City casino
  • 2nd District candidate calls Atlantic City police video of beating disturbing
  • Jury convicts Atlantic City man in fatal stabbing with scissors